Westfalls Christmas Tree Farm

Our take

Westfall’s is about as small and un-fussy as a choose-and-cut operation gets, and that’s not a knock. The Westfall family has run it since 1984, originally as a way to help fund their kids’ college costs, and the record shows nothing that suggests it’s grown into a full agritourism destination since. There’s no shop, no hayride, no hot cocoa stand in the record — just a field of Norway spruce and white pine, a couple of tools, and a flat price.

The pricing actually works in your favor if you go big

Most choose-and-cut farms charge more as trees get taller, which means shoppers on a budget often talk themselves into a smaller tree than they actually want. Westfall’s doesn’t do that. A 2025 WCHS-TV feature reported a flat $40 per tree covering the farm’s full 5-to-10-foot range, and price_from in this record confirms the same $40 figure. That’s real arithmetic worth spelling out: a 10-foot tree costs exactly the same $40 as a 5-foot tree here, so if your living room has the ceiling height, the better value is to size up rather than settle for something smaller to “save money” — there’s no money to save by going smaller. That pricing is not confirmed for 2026, so it’s last season’s number until someone calls and checks, but it’s a real, sourced figure rather than a guess.

Two species, no surprises

The tree selection is short: Norway spruce and white pine. If you’re set on a Fraser or Canaan fir, this isn’t your farm — several others in this directory specialize in fir. If you’re flexible or specifically want a pine or spruce, the narrow list actually simplifies the decision instead of leaving you comparing eight species in a field.

Hours are the real wrinkle

The farm’s standard schedule is weekends only — Friday through Sunday — starting the weekend after Thanksgiving, which falls on November 27, 2026. But research notes describe the operation as informal enough that a weekday visit can be arranged by calling or texting ahead, using a number (304-373-4020) that differs from the farm’s main listed phone (304-354-6424). Neither number is confirmed as current for 2026, and the record doesn’t explain why two numbers exist — it may simply be a personal cell line for one of the Westfalls versus a landline. Either way, if a weekday trip matters to your schedule, call ahead and be ready to try both numbers.

What’s genuinely unknown

Cash-only status isn’t stated either way in this record, so don’t assume plastic works — bring cash or a check as a backup. Hours on any given day (open-to-close times) aren’t documented beyond “weekends,” and there’s no season-end date, so you’re planning around a known opening weekend without a known closing one. None of that is unusual for a farm this size, but it does mean a phone call before you drive out — especially in mid-to-late December — is the responsible move rather than an optional one.

The bottom line

If a flat, arithmetic-friendly $40 price and a simple two-species choice appeal to you, and you’re not put off by weekend-only hours or a farm that runs on personal phone numbers rather than a website, Westfall’s is a legitimately low-risk stop. Just don’t build a weekday trip around it without confirming first.